[p2p-hackers] UDP Hole Punching through Symmetric NATs
lemonobrien at yahoo.com
Wed Jun 15 20:24:12 UTC 2005
i downloaded Rodi source code. I checked out how the NAT stuff worked...and well, didn't understand it too well. it seemed it was using a thread to send messages to itself so it could discover its global port?
would you mind explaining how it works in detail?
larytet.8753341 at bloglines.com wrote:
i make it on dayly basis using http://larytet.sourceforge.net/btRat.shtml
--- Peer-to-peer development."
In my ongoing
quest for real-world data, do you know of any significant
> P2P deployments
that hole-punch through symmetric NATs?
> As you know, the simple
"rendezvous" hole-punching approach described by
> Bryan Ford's paper 
suggests that upwards of 82% of all NATs can have
> holes punched on the
assumption that "consistent endpoint translation"
> is in place (and thanks
to the IETF-BEHAVE group, this number will only
> improve). This means
if you establish outbound UDP sessions from the
> same private endpoint
to two separate locations, your NAT will assign
> the same public endpoint
to each. This allows me to contact you without
> "guessing" what NAT
port you might be using.
>  http://www.brynosaurus.com/pub/net/p2pnat/
> But as Bryan describes, symmetric NATs make no such consistent
translation, and thus each outbound session is assigned a unique public
> endpoint by the NAT. This complicates hole punching, but doesn't
it. To punch through symmetric NATs you must, based on
> knowledge of one
of a peer's public NAT endpoints, intelligently guess
> the others.
> So hole punching through symmetric NATs is difficult, and Bryan suggests
> not worth the effort. I'm curious what you think, however. Have you
> tried it and found it useful in the real world?
> In theory it can
get you better than 82% success ratio of hole punching,
> but I'm not sure
if it gets you only to 85% or 90% or 99% or what. Do
> you know of any
success (or failure) stories of hole punching through
> symmetric NATs in
the real world?
> p2p-hackers mailing list
> p2p-hackers at zgp.org
> Here is a web page listing
p2p-hackers mailing list
p2p-hackers at zgp.org
Here is a web page listing P2P Conferences:
You don't get no juice unless you squeeze
Lemon Obrien, the Third.
Find restaurants, movies, travel & more fun for the weekend. Check it out!
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the P2p-hackers