[linux-elitists] New Yorkers For Fair Use: Boycott All Palladium and TCPA DRM!

Jay Sulzberger jays@panix.com
Wed Jan 22 02:13:39 PST 2003

  edit-level="light, mainly removal of sidebar">

                         New Yorkers For Fair Use

                        Stop Palladium and TCPA now!

   Tell American Megatrends and Transmeta not to make chips that let others
                           control your computer!

    Please use the following form to tell American Megatrends
    and Transmeta not to produce their AMIBIOS8 and TM5800
    chips, and that you will boycott any technology that enables
    TCPA and Palladium technology on your computer:


   What's Going On:

    Last week, Intel, Microsoft, the RIAA and the MPAA announced
    their intention to force Palladium and TCPA into every
    personal computer on the planet.  Palladium and TCPA are a
    different kind of DRM, worse than even the most invasive of
    previously proposed "content control" systems.

    Palladium and TCPA would hardwire your home computer so that
    these four entities and their partners would be able to run
    processes on your computer, entirely outside your control,
    indeed, without your knowledge.

    Below we answer some questions about DRM, Palladium, TCPA, and the

   New Yorkers for Fair Use

   What is DRM?

    DRM is the political, legal, contractual, economic,
    hardware, and software infrastructure designed and intended
    by a loose alliance of cartels and monopolies to take away
    your right to own and privately use a computer.  No full DRM
    exists in the world today, though pieces of DRM have been
    successfully enacted into law and tiny bits of DRM hardware
    and software have been placed in some home movie playing and
    recording devices.  Every single piece of DRM is meant to
    help attain the objective of the anti-ownership alliance: to
    get control of every personal computer in the world.

    Intel and Microsoft and RIAA and MPAA, by their own
    admission, have, to date, spent billions of dollars to force
    universal DRM on the entire world.  Last week these four
    reiterated their intention to force DRM into every personal
    computer on the planet.


    For more on DRM see:


   What is Palladium?

    "Palladium" is Microsoft's name for its proposed DRM system.
    No implementation of Palladium exists today, indeed no
    complete specification of Palladium exists today, but
    certain hardware which a Palladiated operating system
    requires is about to be placed in all personal computers,
    unless we stop Microsoft and its hardware and vendor
    partners, such as Intel, American Megatrends, Transmeta,
    Dell, and CompUSA.

   What will Palladium do?

    Palladium will enable a few large corporations and
    governments to run source secret, indeed, well-encrypted,
    code on home users' machines in such a way that the home
    user cannot see, modify, or control the running code.  A
    Palladiated system is under the complete control of
    Microsoft at all times.  Microsoft might allow some of its
    partners to run code on your machine, but no code will run
    on a Palladiated system without Microsoft's consent.  The
    mechanics are as follows: only code that has been signed
    with a special Microsoft provided key will run.  Microsoft
    will retain at all times the power to revoke any other
    entity's keys.  In particular, no operating system will be
    able to boot without a key from Microsoft.  So if Palladium
    is forced into every home computer, there will be no more
    free software.

    Microsoft will be able to spy on each and every keystroke,
    and mouse movement, and send encrypted messages from your
    machine to Microsoft headquarters.  Microsoft will also be
    able to examine every file on your system.  Your encryption
    programs will not work against Microsoft, or any other
    entities which have full power keys from Microsoft.

   But surely wily crackers and freedom-loving hackers around the world
   will be able to defeat Palladium by breaking it?

    No.  Whether or not a few hackers are able to get around
    some versions of Palladium, most people will not be able to.
    There are two reasons most people will not be able to escape
    the All Seeing Eye and Invisible Hand of Palladium.  First,
    Palladium is not like the absurdly weak systems called "DRM"
    today.  Palladium is both hardware and software, and the
    software is locked to the hardware in a manner completely
    different from today's weak DRM systems.  The design of
    Palladium allows for defense in depth, and even one layer of
    Palladium is harder to crack than any DRM ever seen before.
    Second, under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act of the
    United States of America, it is illegal to try to see what
    Palladium is doing.  It is also illegal to modify the
    hardware of a Palladiated system.  And it is a felony to
    sell advice on how to disable Palladium or its supporting
    hardware.  It is hard enough today to get vendors to sell
    computers with a free operating system already installed.
    Once Microsoft and Intel have forced Palladiated hardware
    into every personal computer, it will be impossible to run a
    free OS.  The very act of booting a free OS will be outlawed
    by application of the DMCA to a Palladiated computer.

   But there are no Palladium systems available today. So how can you
   boycott Palladium?

    We are boycotting the hardware that Palladium needs. Before
    Palladium is rolled out, Palladium-enabling hardware must be
    placed in most of the world's personal computers.  Right now
    such hardware is being placed in computers meant for home
    and business use without the buyer being told.  Our boycott
    is aimed at stopping Palladium-enabling hardware from being
    secretly forced into every personal computer in world.  We
    intend to stop Palladium before we cease to own the
    computers in our own houses and offices.

    The main Palladium-enabling hardware is called a "TPM" for
    Trusted Platform Module.  The TPM hardware will support, in
    addition to Palladium, many different systems which take
    control of the computer away from the user and give control
    to large corporations and government entities.  The TCPA,
    the Trusted Computing Platform Alliance, is the standards
    organization for the TPM.  The founding Alliance members are
    Compaq, HP, IBM, Intel and Microsoft.  Since 1999, the year
    TCPA was founded, about one hundred more companies have
    joined the TCPA.  The Alliance has published a formal
    specification of the TPM.  The TCPA's FAQ


    seeks to allay the natural suspicions of computer buyers
    about what the TPM does.  Unfortunately the FAQ is
    inaccurate on the most important issues.  For example, the
    claim is made that a computer with a working TPM will remain
    under the final, ultimate, and complete control of the user.
    But, as explained above, this is simply untrue.

   So what exactly are you doing?

    We refuse to buy any computer with a TPM inside and we ask
    you to refuse to buy any computer with a TPM inside.  We use
    the term "TPM" to include TPM-like devices, whether in a
    separate chip, in the BIOS chip, or even in the cpu.  This
    means that we ask buyers of personal computers to find out
    whether the computer has a TPM or a TPM-like device inside.
    We will shortly provide buyers of home computers with
    methods for telling whether or not a computer has a TPM

   Is it possible to be more specific today?

    Yes.  We call for a boycott of the just announced
    American Megatrends AMIBIOS8:





    and the just announced Transmeta TM5800 cpu:



   Where can I find out more about Palladium, TCPA, and DMCA?

    For Palladium see:





    For TCPA and the TPM see:


    For the DMCA see:



Distributed poC TINC:

Jay Sulzberger <secretary@lxny.org>
Corresponding Secretary LXNY
LXNY is New York's Free Computing Organization.

More information about the linux-elitists mailing list